Important: The items listed in this section of our site are not for sale. Instead, these are the items we will buy from you in exchange for cash or trade.

Cards sent in for trade for an order receive 50% more than the listed buy prices.

We here at Big Kidz Games LLC, are always looking to buy your Magic the Gathering cards. Whether you have cards that you don’t use or are getting out of Magic all together we are more than willing to take them off your hands. We buy all cards, from common to mythic rare, you can look for what we are buying buy finding it in the menu on the left or buy searching for it by name in the search box. We offer payment via Paypal*, Check, or Store Credit. Customer service is very important to us so we make selling cards to us very fast and easy. All buys are paid within 8 business days after we receive them. To make this process as quick and easy as possible please read and follow the instructions below.


·         You must have an account to the site to sell cards to us.

·         Please use the Buylist cart to sell or trade.

·         Once you have completed adding cards to your Buylist cart click the button marked View Buylist/ Submit on the right side of the page.

·         Review your list and select a payment method.

·         Verify your info and add any comments to go with the order.

·         Enter a ship to address for the order.

·         Click the button marked Submit Buylist near the bottom of the page.

·         You will receive a confirmation E-Mail that we have received your order. (Do not ship anything to us yet!)

·         Once your Buylist is approved you will be sent an E-mail with instructions on what to send and how.

·         We will send an E-Mail once we receive your order.

·         We will grade the cards and send an E-Mail with any corrections to the condition.

·         If no corrections were necessary we will pay immediately.

·         If changes were made based on condition, we will wait 48hrs for response; if no response is received payment will be sent. Payment will be sent sooner if you respond to and approve the revised order.

·         Finally you will receive and E-Mail notifying you of Payment sent.

As always your sale or trade is appreciated very much!


·         Played cards are purchased at a lower price.

·         Cost of shipping cards to Big Kidz Games LLC are paid by the seller.

·         Store credit can be used towards any merchandise on our website or in our store.

·         If you don’t use your full credit amount it will be stored in the system for future use.

·         If you go over your credit amount you will be able to use other payment methods (Paypal, Credit Card,) to pay for the difference.


Please contact us if you have any questions!

*Please note that if you elect to receive payment via Paypal, some fees may apply. These fees are detailed here.

Need Help With Checkout?

Our phone lines are open!
(616) 608-3532
Mon: Closed
Tues – Thurs: 3pm to 11pm
Fri: 3pm to 2am
Sat: 10am to 12am
Sun: 12pm to 8pm

Buylist Cart

You have no items on your buylist.

Welcome, Guest.  
Join Us on Facebook
Follow Us On Twitter
Designed & powered by © 2021 Big Kidz Games. All Rights Reserved.
Home | Buylist | Calendar | Contact | Policies